Cichocka H., J.Z. Lichański, , Zarys historii retoryki, Warszawa. Foss S.K. Korolko M., , Sztuka retoryki. Perelman Ch., , Imperium retoryki, tł. quotations based on the Polish edition: Chaďm Perelman, Imperium retoryki. Retoryka i argumentacja [Empire of rhetoric. Rhetoric and argumentation]. Chaim Perellman – Imperium Retoryki ()Documents · Binyan Halacha – Rav Chaim ZimmermanDocuments · Chaim Shapiro LinkedIn
|Published (Last):||19 October 2015|
|PDF File Size:||11.55 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||14.76 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Since the activities of the Polish Home Army and the Underground State did not reflect the communist hierarchy of values, they were con- sidered to belong to the same category as the actions under- taken by Rstoryki Germany Przewodnik encyklopedyczny, Warszawa Kraus J.
The Rhetoric of Prudence in Stanisław Herakliusz Lubomirski’s De vanitate consiliorum
O dowodach soistycznych [Topics. Retoryka i argumentacja [Empire of rhetoric. State- ments about being a member of the Home Army and the authorities of the Polish Underground State, presented by the defendants, constituted the basis to draw the conclusion about anti-Soviet activity or about the murders on civilians and soldiers of the Red Army On eristic methods used by Stalinist courts… 35 would be to develop argumentation without paying attention to the reactions of the interlocutor who obligatorily passes from the role of a passive listener to active participant of the conversation.
Vossius]; Polish tradition Next, the two abovementioned political trials will be briefly described, constituting the basis for the presenta- tion of eristic misuses.
Imperium retoryki: retoryka i argumentacja – Chaim Perelman – Google Books
The concept of a universal auditorium is essentially ideal and formal in nature. Argumentation aims at influencing the listeners, at modifying their beliefs and attitudes by means of speech whose goal is to obtain their The public prosecutor at the end of the trial of the Sixteen: Prudentia is referred to by the characters of the dialogue as a faculty that allows the statesman to make detoryki best of contradictory forces influencing the course of political affairs — a faculty which does not ensure success, but allows one to achieve the best possible result in the contingent sphere of human affairs.
Ricoeur Paul, Critique and Conviction: Zakazana retoryka [Hand- book of manipulation. As for his stay in the camps see: Stelmach, Kodeks argumentacyjny…, op. Civil disobedience], Wydawnictwo Aletheia, War- szawap.
Pragmatic argument, as Perelman writes, which seems to reduce the value of the cause to the value Ch. On eristic methods used by Stalinist courts… 13 audience31; in the case of the latter, the argumentation is effective when it is accepted by at least part of it LXXI, Book 4 Rhethoric Practice, part II reoryki exercises for students Liniarski, that the testimony against Fieldorf was enforced on him.
Chaim Gravitzer Vol. 2
Jankowski died of heart disease. Judgment was executed the following day. Totalitarian power used quite the opposite scheme, preliminarily creating a dependent audience — the defendants, the press, etc. Andrzeja Frycza Modrzewskiego pieniazekm poczta.
The situation of the accused was even more deteriorated by the inaccessi- bility of ideologized sources of the Soviet positive law. The author cites the opinion of the post-war prosecutor general: The notion of prudence as practical judgement in retotyki to affairs of state is linked here to the Ciceronian mode of arguing in utramque partem, allowing a careful examination of different aspects of any given issue before taking political action.
It should be noticed that the philosopher introduced also a concept of particular 24 Ch. This course is not currently offered.
Copyright by Retory,i of Warsaw.
They can be under- stood as forms of violence occurring in the language of the judicial discourse participants judges, prosecutorsaimed at the total elimination of political opponents. Formal aspects of court argumentation What is also worth mentioning are some formal aspects of the argumentation used by the Stalinist courts. Adjusting to the audience primarily consists in cho- osing such premises as argumentation of these thesis which were acknowledged by the audience. According to Perelman the aim of every argumentation is to encourage or reinforce the support of the statements sub- mitted to the acceptance of certain auditorium Quasi-logical argument requires, if we can say so, including reality in spatial structure which would exclude characteristic particular situations, like permeating, interacting, luidity The students are to learn not about the history of rhethoric but the formation of tool to examine any text according to requirements that were put by the authors.
Firstly, they relied on the instrumentation of the auditorium, that is, on the rejection of the mechanism for assessing the rationality of the argu- ments raised in the discourse in the courtroom. Rhetorica ad Hernnium; M. Moreover, it is possible to link them with the entire propaganda argumentation used in that period An interpretation of the dialogue as a rhetorical exercise in prudence is proposed in this part, arguing that the way Lubomirski employs rhetorical deliberation in utramque partem invites the reader to constantly exercise his own practical judgement in relation to affairs of state.
Halina Kur- kowska Ed. It was then a quasi — logical necessity that the one who did not cooperate with the Red Army, behaved similarly to the Nazis Liniarski was brought to the hearing room on the stretcher. Fur- ther techniques used by the communist courts consisted, inter alia, in hiding the ideological content in formalized legal rea- soning and in sociotechnical manipulation in the courtroom.
The audience was additionally manipulated during the trial, particularly by means of misuses in the sphere of such notions as the truth, fact, supposition and value.